Brickipedia:Articles for Rating/Class 1/Clone Scout Trooper

Articles for Rating → Class 1 article nominations → Archive → Clone Scout Trooper

This page is an archive. Please do not modify it.

Nominated by: ~~Jeyo~~ Lord Vladek Talk The Forge
Nomination comments: Added a larger, clearer image, greatly expanded the description to include every detail, expanded the background and added a notes section.

Vote score: ±2, Technical Check: Currently OK[edit source]

Support

Weak support Not entirely sure, it feels as though something is missing but I can't pin-point what... User:SKP4472/sig3 20:10, September 1, 2012 (UTC)
Support per SKP, I feel it should have something. It isn't a very large description for a usual C1 article. However, I think it covers as best as it possibly can for a rather exclusive Minifigure that has only appeared in one set. So I support it for now. -User:Power Jim/sigcode 09:18, September 4, 2012 (UTC)
Support The article covers the Clone Scout Trooper minifigure as best as it can. User:Darth henry/Sig 13:30, September 12, 2012 (UTC)

Object

After much thought, I've finally sorted out my opinions on this. While it is, really, quite an amazing article for what it is, it doesn't really measure up to the C1 standard. If we judged C1's by how well they cover the material, then I would support. However, we don't. I really hate saying this, but "it just doesn't have the potential". User:Cligra/Sig

Technical MoS Check (QCG members only)
Comments

Please rate! I've improved it now. ~~Jeyo~~ Lord Vladek Talk The Forge

I don't know, though if anything I'm neutral, leaning slightly to support. Agent Charge 07:38, September 1, 2012 (UTC)
- Not to be mean, but I don't get it. He only appears in one set, and when I requested Aurra Sing and Bossk for C1, they were closed because they weren't C1 potential. Clone Scout Trooper only appears in one set... What NBS said: "As I said, I think it's a high-end C2, but I just don't think it's C1 potential (it's not you, it's just that it's only about a single minifigure). Wouldn't oppose it being a c1 though, but can't support either, sorry." User:LSCStealthNinja/RealSig

In answer to some: true, this article's description and background are not as large as some other c1 article's are, but for a minifigure with 1 variation and that has maybe 2 minutes of screen time in the movie, it's fairly large. ~~Jeyo~~ Lord Vladek Talk The Forge Done. Closed and upgraded by Captain Jag NovaHawk 02:44, September 15, 2012 (UTC)