|[List of appearances]|
Tony One-Time is one of Vinnie Pappalardo's most well-known gang members, known for saying things only once. He is seen in Pappalardo's ice cream parlour having a conversation with some women, and says "hi" to Chase McCain. Upon realising that he has said that before, the camera focuses on him and the women are surprised.
- He and other Pappalardo gang members are homages to the film Goodfellas, where he is based on Jimmy Two Times.