14,954
edits
:*who ever said my idea entailed a big banner? --[[User:ToaMeiko|ToaMeiko]] ([[User talk:ToaMeiko|talk]]) 04:40, 3 July 2014 (UTC)
:*I don't mind keeping small ratings in the corner (as long as they have descriptive names like "complete" and "stub", not c4 or c2 or whatever, but also if it is a stub, then I think we should use the stub template to as then people are definitely gonna see it and are therefore more likely to improve it. (as in, when I come across a page, I don't look at the ratings - its not in the main field of view. A template is.) [[User:CJC95|CJC95]] ([[User talk:CJC95|talk]]) 20:29, 3 July 2014 (UTC)
::*I don't think stub is an obvious choice of word seeing as we're trying to appeal to children not teenagers. {{User:Soupperson1/Sig}}
::Surely it's obvious when a stub is a stub without the banner though? [[User:UltrasonicNXT|UltrasonicNXT]] ([[User talk:UltrasonicNXT|talk]])
:::To us veterans maybe, but to new/non-users, a banner saying "You can help improve this by blah de blah" would be more likely to get to them to edit then just thinking "well, this page is short". [[User:CJC95|CJC95]] ([[User talk:CJC95|talk]]) 21:37, 3 July 2014 (UTC)
|